Sunday, June 24, 2012

What does the 9th and New Hampshire proposal teach us about out development controls?

What does the 9th and New Hampshire proposal teach us about our development controls?


Lawrence lacks proper development controls. The absence of proper controls prevents the City from reviewing major projects and allows developers to dictate the pace of growth. This is a mistake.

The problems with the 9th and New Hampshire proposal are a text book example of failed planning.


Quick history:

The City approved zoning on the 900 block of New Hampshire for the Downtown 2000 project. The Downtown 2000 project failed. It was supposed to pay for one-half of the New Hampshire Street parking garage. When the project failed, the taxpayers had to pick up the tab for the garage.

Despite the failure of the project, the zoning lives on at the site. This permits the developer to proceed with a hotel without normal planning review. If the developer wants to build a 3-story hotel and does not want subsidy, it can be built without planning review. The proposed hotel never went through the Planning Commission and as such, the community at large and the neighborhood in particular was not given the opportunity to weigh in on the strengths and weaknesses of this project.

The only reason that the project is going before the City Commission is because it happens to be located adjacent to historic properties making it subject to review by the Historic Resources Commission (HRC), and the project failed to win HRC approval.

The process going forward:

The City Commission will hear an appeal of the decision of the HRC. The scope of the City Commission’s review is narrow. It is to determine whether or not the owner of the property can develop feasible projects under current zoning that will not harm adjacent historic properties. In this setting, feasibility means that a development will earn enough cash flow to attract investors. Generally, this cash flow has to return about 10 percent annually over a period of 10 years. There is little question that feasible alternatives exist. Three-story projects are feasible if no parking garage is included. Town Peterson demonstrates this in his submission to the City Commission. If a parking garage is added to the development, then a project is probably not feasible without deep subsidy. The report from Springsted finds that subsidy will be needed to make a project feasible if it contains a parking garage.

The City Commission cannot, in good conscience, find that no feasible alternative exists under current zoning. It is clear that a three-story retail/office facility will generate a competitive return on investment.

To the developer, the problem is not the percentage return on investment with a three-story project; it is the dollar amount of profit. The developers can make more money with a larger development that includes five or six stories, a hotel, and a parking garage with that garage paid for by the taxpayers.

How did Lawrence get into this problem?

Lawrence is in this problem because of a lack of proper development controls. Because the zoning did not end with the death of the Downtown 2000 project, the City has lost much of its capacity to control this project.

Some version of the proposal at 9th and New Hampshire may be a development that the City, the East Lawrence Neighborhood Association, the Historic Resources Commission and the community at large may all support. But we will never know under the current development controls because there is no opportunity to debate the project. There is constrained review of its impact on adjacent historic properties, but the HRC review is not supposed to go beyond this narrow issue. Assuming that the developers will seek deep subsidies on the property, there will be some debate over whether or not the project should be given costly subsidies, but again, the debate will be unfairly narrowed to this topic.

The process as being played out now will not permit the community to weigh in on the height of this project, the timing of this project nor the impact of the project on our downtown and other hotel projects.


What should be done about this problem?

Lawrence needs a set of development controls that permit the City to dictate not only the height, bulk and use of a project but also the timing of when these projects are built.

Zoning dictates the height bulk and use of a project. Clearly our zoning does not do this well. The current proposal seeks to go higher than the rules permit, but this decision is not reviewed by the Planning Commission or the City Commission. The development controls of the city should mandate that any significant project must go through review by the Planning Commission with a public hearing procedure.

Lawrence needs a set of development controls that allow it to set the pace of growth. In this, the City is woefully lacking. The City’s development controls assume that once zoned, the private market knows best how to time development. We are now in the fifth year of a real estate driven recession because of the error of this assumption. The private market is prone to overbuilding as developers seek to cannibalize business from each other, a practice the leaves cities pock marked with failed shopping centers and neighborhoods with too much vacancy and disinvestment.

Lawrence is paying the price for letting the development community dictate the pace of growth.

Lawrence’s retail space grew faster than retail spending. From 1997 to 2007, retail spending grew by 26% but new space added 36% to the stock of space, producing over 500,000 square feet of surplus space. The surplus resulted in chronic vacancies downtown, along 23rd Street and in various neighborhood centers. The market has consumed about one-half of that surplus, but with the current economic downturn, it will take a long time to work through the remainder of the surplus. Yet the City continues to approve more retail space as if the problem does not exist.

Lawrence’s housing stock expanded faster than the growth in its population. From 2000 to 2007, the counts of households grew by 4,500, but developers built 5,700 housing units, creating a surplus of 1,200 units. The surplus is equivalent to a dozen large subdivisions, enough to cover the city’s needs for more than 6 years, devastating the housing industry.

Now the City is confronting a similar problem with its hotels. The taxpayers invested $11 million in the Oread Hotel. The City has an interest in the Eldridge Hotel surviving because it uniquely defines our historic downtown. Recently the City approved zoning for a hotel as part of the North Mass Development. The City is rezoning property at 6th Street and the South Lawrence Trafficway for a sports complex with a retail shopping center and a hotel. As if all of this is not enough, the developers of 9th and New Hampshire propose yet another hotel.

The City lacks development controls that place it in a position to: 1.) Determine that pace at which it can absorb new space, and 2.) Regulate the pace of new construction so as to prevent overbuilding.

Right now, no one in the planning process seems to know how many additional hotel rooms the City can absorb without harm to its existing hotels and its existing investments. Even if this was known, the City does not have the power to control the pace at which space is added. Once zoned, the developers control the pace of development, even if that pace is harmful to City investments and City interests.

What should the development controls include?

Market Analysis: The City’s development controls should provide for the City to study its own markets and determine how much space it can absorb each year, whether the space is composed of housing units, retail stores, offices or hotel rooms.

Growth Management: The City’s development controls should provide mechanisms for the City to set the pace of development so as to keep the pace of growth within the capacity of the City’s market to absorb that space. If we learn nothing else from the crash of 2008, we should learn that the real estate industry does not pace itself well. Rather than allowing developers to create problems, we should force developers to compete against each other so that only the very best projects go forward.

Benefit-Cost Analysis: The City’s development controls should examine the benefits and costs of each significant development. For too long, we have assumed that each project, if properly zoned, is good for the community. This assumption is wrong. Many new projects serve only to pull demand away from other, usually older, neighborhoods and shopping districts creating depressed values and disinvestment. The City needs to better understand the implications of each new development upon existing properties. Often the benefits of the new development do not justify the costs to the older neighborhoods.

Feasibility and Efficiency Analysis: The City’s development controls should examine project feasibility where subsidies are requested. The City does this, but too often, the City takes the approach that if the project is not feasible without subsidy, then the subsidy should be granted. Full feasibility analysis should examine whether other, less costly, alternatives will serve the City’s needs adequately. We should not give the presumption of validity to the developer’s proposals. Often an alternative proposal, including doing nothing, will serve the community’s interests better. Searching for this better alternative needs to become a part of the development process.

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Is the revised Joint Economic Development Council all that it could be?

I read with interest the revisions to the proposed Joint Economic Development Council that is before the City Commission.  The City Commission must ask itself, is this the best path to effective local economic development planning?
The answer is no.

Representation

The proposed Council now includes four community representatives to counter the five Chamber of Commerce representatives.  This falls short of equal representation which would enhance the standing of this body.  As long as the Chamber of Commerce retains too much control of the Council, its advice will be viewed with suspicion by the community at large. 

It is worth noting that the community representatives do not necessarily come from any of the many community and neighborhood organizations who could provide valuable input.  Thus, there is nothing to prevent a pro-Chamber City Commission or County Commission from appointing additional pro-Chamber individuals to these positions.

If this body is to gain the respect of the community and is to provide valuable advice, it is important that it be seen as truly representative of the community at large.  As revised, the Council falls short.



Professionalism

Local economic development planning is complex and requires professional expertise.  Virtually every city in the nation is in the game, and playing the game successfully requires an in-depth knowledge of what works, why it works, and what it takes to make it work here.  Too many cities, implement economic development strategies by following advocacy and ideology rather than following research based professional guidance.



The City and the County continue to give over $400,000 per year to the Chamber of Commerce and get too little in return.  The Chamber is a business advocacy organization.  Advocacy has its place, but it is not the way to succeed in local economic development planning.  The record of the City in its failed economic development programs is testament to the inherent flaws in following advocacy.



Professionalism is the path to successful local economic development planning.  At the moment, the City is staffed by a single profession economic development coordinator.  Creating this position was a step in the right direction, but it was only a good first step.  More professional planners are needed.



Currently, the community is confronting many issues that require the input of these planners.  These questions include:  Can the city absorb all of the additional hotel rooms that are proposed downtown?  Can the city absorb the additional retail space proposed as part of the sports complex?  Can the city attract enough events to make such a sports complex viable?  Will there be enough demand for downtown vendors that the city can use of tax increment financing successfully to support other services such as the Lawrence Arts Center? Are the City’s investments in industrial and biotech performing well?



Additional professional local economic development planners could provide the guidance and instruction that an advisory board, such as the Joint Economic Development Council, needs.  Just being a business or community representative does not mean that the representative is knowledgeable on matters of selecting, designing and implementing effective economic development strategies.  Advocates paid by the Chamber of Commerce cannot provide the full truth; they must adhere to the ideology of their employer.  Professional planners who report to the City and County Commissions can provide this evidence driven expertise.





Recommendation



Further refine the composition of the Joint Economic Development Council to ensure that the community representatives truly represent the community at large and are, at least, equal in number to the representatives from the Chamber of Commerce.



Bring economic development planning inside City Hall and inside the County Court House.  Reduce the role of the Chamber of Commerce in economic development planning and increase the role of professional planners who bring expertise to the process and who report only to the elected commissioners.


Thursday, June 07, 2012

How do we select a sports complex in Northwest Lawrence?

Deciding on a Sports Complex in Northwest Lawrence

The Lawrence Parks and Recreation Advisory Board held a public session to exchange ideas about the proposed sports complex.  Here a a couple of recommendations on how to proceed.

Compared to what?

Too much of the discussion last evening cast the decision the City Commission will make on the sports complex as a choice between the proposed 50 acre sports complex at the SLT versus doing nothing.  This is an overly stark and unfair characterization of the choices.  What the taxpayers and the City Commission need is a better representation of the choices.

A more correct representation of the choices would be:

1.        A 50 acre, 8 basketball/volleyball court complex in partnership with the KU Athletic Association with a soccer field and a track field.  To adopt this option means to give the developer permission to build a retail complex of about 200,000 square feet in exchange for a land donation of 50 acres, much of which was intended to be undeveloped as a buffer for property owners to the north.  This alternative requires a large investment in infrastructure, but it has the potential to attract tournaments and events to Lawrence.

2.       A 35 acre, 4 (or maybe more) basketball/volleyball court complex built to the west of Free State High School permitting the complex to be used in conjunction with the facilities at the school.  The zoning and preliminary plans for this complex are available.  This alternative does not involve increasing the retail stock, which is now overbuilt.  This alternative does not require as much new infrastructure as the alternative west of the SLT. This Overland Drive alternative involves a partnership between the City and USD 497 rather than a partnership with KUAA.  This alternative also has the potential to attract tournaments and events to Lawrence.

Recommendation:  As you move forward with analysis of a sport complex in Northwest Lawrence, please provide a comparison between these two alternatives so that the decision makers are making informed choice over two options.

Where is the Market Analysis?

I have yet to hear of any professional market analysis conducted to guide the decision makers. 

The presentation on the Frisco, Texas complex was interesting, but potentially misleading.  Frisco is bigger, richer city that sits within a much, much larger metroplex.  We are Lawrence; we need to guide the taxpayers into an investment that can be sustained by a city of our size and ability to pull in outsiders.  Knowing the scale of sustainable investment takes skill.  This skill has in short supply in Lawrence, and we are paying the price.  The Riverfront Mall was a failure, and the taxpayers continue to pay the price of the failed project and its parking garage.  The Downtown 2000 project was a failure, and the taxpayers continue to pay the price of the failed project and its parking garage.  These mistakes were made because the City moved forward with projects that were inadequately researched.

I had occasion to be in Gainesville, Florida last week.  Takeaway the alligators and the Spanish moss hanging from the trees, and Gainesville is much like Lawrence.  I picked up the local newspaper and read a front page investigative report on the disappointing performance of the City’s investment in a new sports complex.  The project is relatively new and construction delays occurred, but the sports complex had not attracted the tournaments projected for it.  This complex may recover and perform well in the future, but the experience of Gainesville is instructive.  It teaches us to be realistic about our capacity to attract tournaments.

It is fine to dream big, but when we invest, we should make sure that we invest wisely.  If we invest too big, hoping to realize our dreams, we may lose big.  If we invest based upon realistic expectations, we may have a better chance of realizing sustainable return on our investment.  We do not want an investigative article in a future issue of the Lawrence Journal World to report on the disappointing performance of the new sports complex to attract visitors, straddling the taxpayers with another poorly performing investment.

Recommendation:  Before we go much further, Lawrence needs to engage some expertise that will guide the city in terms of projecting a realistic level of demand for tournaments and its associated hotel, restaurant and retail spending so as to guide the choice of the scale of a sports complex.


Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Should the City Purchase 4950 Research Parkway?

A number of issues should be resolved as the City of Lawrence, Kansas considers the purchase and operation of the builiding at 4950 Research Parkway.


Background

The Lawrence Douglas County Biosciences Authority (LDCBA) proposes that the city purchase the property at 4050 Research Parkway for $2,900,000.

This purchase would be financed through issuing general obligation bonds.

LDCBA would operate as the property manager and leasing agent. The property would be leased, in part, to the firm CritiTech. Other firms would be sought to lease the remainder of the building.

The financial projections for the property anticipate that it would not generate sufficient income to cover the costs of operation and that the taxpayers of Lawrence and Douglas County would subsidize the property to cover the losses.


Issues

1. Purchase price

The proposed purchase price is $2,900,000. The financial projections for the property show the property generating a net operating income of about $12 per square foot. It also assumes a capitalization rate (net operating income / property value) of about 6 percent which is too low. Capitalization rates should reflect the cost of borrowing, the return on equity invested in such properties, and the risk associated with this type of space. This suggests a capitalization rate of 8 percent or higher. With a capitalization rate of 8 percent, the purchase price of the property should be $2,300,000, and this assumes that the building can maintain 89 percent occupancy. If the occupancy falls to a lower level, the value of the property will be lower, possibly much lower.

2. Identity of interest between the seller and the tenant


The purchase price becomes immediately suspect because one of the current owners of the property is a principal in the CritiTech firm which is to be a subsidized occupant of the property. The sellers have an interest in obtaining as high a price as possible for the property, even a price higher than it can command in the private market. CritiTech as an occupant has an interest in leasing the space at a low lease rate, even a rate that is below the market rate because it is subsidized. With no arm’s length separation between the seller and the tenant, the taxpayer cannot trust either the purchase price or the lease rate.

This suggests that the city should closely investigate the calculations of the purchase price and lease rates to ensure that the taxpayers are not being asked to provide more subsidies than are necessary.


3. Form of financing

The proposal is for the city to issue general obligation bonds to finance the purchase of the property. This obligates the city to cover all principal and interest payments on the debt if the property does not generate sufficient income.

It is more common for projects of this type to be financed with revenue bonds. With revenue bonds, the city promises only the revenues from the project for payment of the debt. Revenue bonds insulate the taxpayers from a heavy financial burden if the project fails.

This is a highly risky project. This risk will raise the interest rate on revenue bond debt, if the debt can be issued at all. If the project is too risky to be financed with revenue bonds, it suggests that the project is too risky for to be undertaken.

If the city wants to purchase this property, the city needs to explore financing mechanisms that minimize the risk absorbed by the taxpayers.


4. Projected occupancy

The financial projection for the property assumes that the project will achieve 89 percent occupancy after 4 years and will maintain that level of occupancy for the remaining 21 years of the bond financing.

This is an eleven year old property with a checkered history. The property’s occupancy levels over its life need to be detailed. It seems highly unlikely that this property will suddenly transform from a poor performing property to a fully occupied property and remain fully occupied for over two decades.

The city should closely examine the occupancy history of the property and should examine the market for such laboratory space. The market is saturated with facilities being offered to bioscience firms. It is unlikely that this property will attract firms from outside of Lawrence; all of the firms are likely to come from spin-offs of KU.

A compelling case needs to be made that KU will produce sufficient firms to maintain 89 percent occupancy in this property for over two decades, despite the fact that KU has not produced these firms in the past.


5. Property taxes

The LDCBA proposal states that the property will remain a taxable property. This is not correct. If the city is to own the property, it is not a taxable property. Under some circumstances, a tenant could be charged a lease rate that is high enough to cover the debt on the property and an amount that would be paid in property taxes had the property been taxable. This is usually referred to as a payment in lieu of taxes or PILOT.

The financial projection for the property shows a PILOT, but it also shows that the project will not generate sufficient revenue to cover its own costs. The losses are covered by the taxpayers.

It is disingenuous to claim that the property is on the tax rolls when it is publicly owned and will generate losses that must be covered by the taxpayers.

The proposal should not mislead the taxpayers into thinking that this property will be anything other than a subsidized property.



Recommendation

There is nothing wrong with the city exploring mechanisms to foster economic development in the biosciences. However, the city should exercise caution so as to not expose the taxpayers to unnecessary risk or unjustifiable costs.

This proposal merits further exploration, but there are many flaws and misrepresentations in the proposal. It can be seen as a starting point rather than an ending point. The city should negotiate for a better agreement. It is possible that a better agreement can be found that is mutually acceptable to all parties. The current proposal appears to be prohibitively flawed.

The City Commission should direct staff to study this property more closely and determine whether a feasible financial package can be constructed with minimal risk to the taxpayers.

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

What are reasonable expectations for local economic development?

What is economic development?

It is important to understand the definition of economic development. Economic development is expanding the total income of a community. Expanding the total income means attracting dollars into the community from outside the community. This can be through attracting tourists or new retirees, attracting new customers who live outside of the community to businesses already in the community, attracting new businesses to the community that sell their products or services outside of the community, or any action that raises the wages of the labor force by bringing dollars into the community.

The most essential ingredient for successful economic development is the maintenance and development of a high quality of living in the community. This means making the community a place where people what to live, where workers are well educated, and where firms want to do business.

Necessary ingredients for successful economic development

Labor

A community must have a appropriately trained labor force. Warehousing requires little or no training. Manufacturing usually requires a well-trained labor force. Professional services can require a highly educated labor force. Lawrence generally enjoys a highly educated labor force. In the U.S. 16% of adults did not complete high school; in Lawrence only 4% did not complete high school. In the U.S. 25% of adults have a college degree; in Lawrence it is 35%. We need to seek employment opportunities that match the composition of the labor force.

A community has to have the right quantity and quality of labor available. If the labor force is too small or not available, then the community will not be attractive. This is usually not a big problem as most new firms are looking for only a small number of employees. Douglas County contains 47,000 workers; most new firms will add fewer than 100 employees.

The labor in a community has to be competitively priced. Unfortunately, Lawrence excels in this dimension. Wages in Lawrence are low in virtually all occupations. Thus, wages are not held down by student labor; wages are low across the board. This makes Lawrence attractive to firms, but sadly it is making Lawrence unattractive to workers.

Land

A community needs to have an adequate supply of appropriately serviced land available. Adequate means the right amount, not too much and not too little. Too often communities are led into preparing large quantities of land that only sits idle. It is unwise to develop more land than can be reasonable absorbed within a decade.

No self-contained community like Lawrence is going to attract an extremely large employer needing a very large site. Virtually all of the firms moving into Lawrence over the last two decades developed on parcels of 25 acres, more or less. While new land for future employment centers may be needed, it is doubtful that the number of acres needed cannot be accommodated by existing sites and by the Farmland Industries site. Remember that the University of Kansas remains the largest employer, and it has provided for its own growth. The community only needs to provide for the non-University growth.

Loans

A community is often called upon to provide financing for business expansion and development. As long as this is done in a way that minimizes or eliminates the risk to the taxpayers, this can be a successful tool to facilitate economic development.

Public sector loans can subsidize a development, but they cannot create demand for the product or service to be produced. It is important to remember that subsidized financing can help a good investment succeed, but it will not turn a risky investment into a safe one. Cautious underwriting is required.


Many things do not work:

Tax abatements

Property taxes comprise such a small portion of the operating expenses of manufacturing or research and development facilities that abatements cannot influence a successful firm’s location decision. Property tax abatements are a waste of scarce resources. They have failed in Lawrence, and they have failed elsewhere.

Speculative development

Building structures on a speculative basis is highly risky. Too often they sit empty and only lose money. This has been the case in Lawrence.

Equally, a community must avoid speculative provision of expensive infrastructure in the hope of attracting new development. Lawrence has often failed in this area as well.

Free land

The price of land in the Midwest is sufficiently inexpensive that it does not influence the location decision of firms. Note that Abilene provides free land but has a low job growth rate while Johnson County charges high land prices and has a much higher job growth rate.

Hasty planning

The amount of time it takes to plan and development a project in Lawrence is comparable to the time it takes in other communities. It is not true that Lawrence takes longer; this is a myth pushed by those who oppose careful planning. Good planning takes a reasonable amount of time in Lawrence, just like it does everywhere else.



Practical realities of economic development

Thousands of communities across the nation are engaged in economic development, yet only a few hundred firms will build significant new facilities in any single year. This means that the job growth rate in Lawrence will be driven the natural expansion and contraction of existing firms and only rarely will a new firm be added to the mix.

Manufacturing is declining in Lawrence as it is for the nation as a whole. While manufacturing jobs pay well, Lawrence is going to lose its share of these jobs, and the return of these jobs is not likely in the foreseeable future.

Lawrence should avoid repeating the mistakes that it and other communities have made in the past in the false belief that these efforts improve the competitive position of the city in attracting tourists, new residents, and new businesses. Lawrence should continue to improve the quality of its work force, seek to raise the wage levels of the work force, and seek to make Lawrence a community where everyone wants to live.

Saturday, February 28, 2009

Is it time to impose a long cooling off period on development?

Watching the market work and fail to correct itself.

Too often our elected officials subscribe to the false notion that all construction is good. They adhere to the "build it and they will come" theory of real estate development. This theory falsely holds the new supply creates demand. One need only look around Lawrence to see the error in this type of thinking. We have empty homes, apartments, retail stores, and offices throughout the community. In fact, demand ebbs and flows; the supply that can be supported is not a function of what we build but of the amount of demand that exists in the community.

The success of our real estate markets depends upon us keeping the supply in balance with the demand.

Why is this? The development industry is not good at pacing itself; it is prone to overbuilding. When it overbuilds, the taxpayers suffer.

We pay for the roads, utilities, plus police and fire protection for these excess developments. Example: Since 2000, the developers built over 3,200 home more homes than the population growth would support. The only good thing that you can say for the current credit market freeze is that it called a halt to the overbuilding spree.

We also suffer from the blight created by the reduced value to the neighborhoods surrounding the empty space. Example: North Lawrence is hurt by the blighting effect of the dead Tanger Mall.

We all lose directly through lost investment in redevelopment plans. Example: The empty $8 million parking garage in the 800 block of New Hampshire Street. The City built the garage on the promise that a developer would redevelop the surrounding area in mixed-use buildings. All that was built was the small building that contains PepperJax. The rest of the development was halted by the overbuilding that created too much competing space, mostly in the west side of town.

We lose indirectly through the diminished efforts to redevelop our downtown. Examples: The Hobbs-Taylor Building is unable to attract retail tenants and the redeveloped 600 block of Massachusetts Street has vacancies. These two attractive developments should be the most valuable space in town. Unfortunately, the City has done its best to hurt these investments in our downtown by approving excessive amounts of competing retail space elsewhere, more space than the spending in Lawrence will support.

Two quick facts show the pace of the overbuilding:


1. From 2000 through 2007, the builders built 800 homes per year when the population added only 400 households per year. Over and eight-year period, this was about 3,200 surplus homes.

2. From 2000 through 2007, the builders built over 160,000 square feet of retail space per year when the growth in retail spending would support only 50,000 square feet per year.
This shows that the construction industry was vastly oversized, and we are now paying for it.
We need a City Commission that will keep the construction industry in check. It is not that hard to keep the pace of growth of housing in line with the growth of population. The City simply needs to plan for the pace of growth, approving only as many subdivisions as are really needed. It is not that hard to keep the pace of growth of retail space in line with the growth in retail spending. The City simply needs to pace the growth, approving only as many new shopping centers as the growth in retail spending will support.

This has been made harder by the current City Commission’s excessive allegiance to developers. The City Commission has approved virtually every development approval brought before it when the market analysis told it that the city could not absorb all of the new space without harming existing developments. Because of this excessive amount of space both recently built and under construction, the city needs a long cooling off period.

The economic recession is having some positive effect in that is it slowed down the building spree. However, recession is too crude a tool for this job. The City Commission should have managed the pace of growth in real estate, keeping it in line with the growth in demand for that real estate. Having failed to do that, we must now recognize that it will be a long time before we will need any significant additions to the supply. We have too many single-family homes. We have too many apartments. We have too many retail stores. We must wait for the demand to absorb this space before adding to this damaging oversupply. If we fail to impose a cooling off period, the development industry will only repeat its mistakes as soon as the recession bottoms out and credit markets thaw.

We should learn from out mistakes and prevent future cycles of overbuilding. It is what good planning and good growth management is all about.


Thursday, December 11, 2008

What should citizens of Lawrence expect from its City Commission for the development of its housing stock?

What should citizens of Lawrence expect from its City Commission for the development of its housing stock?

The City Commission failed to reign in the excessive growth of the housing stock brought on by the developers. The taxpayers now pay the price for this excessive growth.

In any community, it is the goal of a city to maintain balance between the demand for housing and the supply of housing. If the supply runs ahead of demand, values fall. If the supply runs ahead of demand for a long period of time, whole neighborhoods lose value and blight occurs. Older neighborhoods suffer especially hard. This is what has happened in Lawrence.


Growth in the population is a good measure of growth in demand for housing

In Lawrence:

From1990 to 2000, the population grew:
· About 700 households per year,
· About 2.0 percent per year.

From 2000 to 2007, the population grew more slowly at:
· About 400 households per year,
· About 1.7 percent per year.

Growth in the number of housing units is a good measure of growth in the supply of housing

In Lawrence:

From 1990 to 2000, the housing stock grew:
· About 900 units per year,
· About 3.0 percent per year.

Since 2000, the housing stock grew:
· About 800 units per year,
· About 2.1 percent per year.

Matching the growth of demand and the growth of supply

In a well-planned market there should be a close correspondence between the growth in population and the growth in supply of housing. Developers have added units at a much greater rate than the growth in population:

· During the 1990s, the growth of supply outpaced the growth of demand by 200 units per year.
· Since 2000, the growth of supply outpaced the growth of demand by 400 units per year.
· The surplus stock totals to about 5,000 units. This means that developers have built surplus units that are more than the size of Eudora, all within the city limits of Lawrence.

Implications:


· The surplus has brought about an out-migration from older neighborhoods, mostly in the eastern parts of the city, resulting in a loss of units.
· The loss of units resulted in a loss of value and deterioration in
the city’s older neighborhoods.

What should citizens of Lawrence expect from its City Commission?

· In a growing community, there is no need for any neighborhood to suffer a loss of population, housing units, or property values.
· In a growing community, the City Commission and its planners should manage growth to keep the pace of growth of supply in balance with the growth in demand for that housing.
· The City Commission and its planners should direct sufficient investment into older neighborhoods so that they maintain value and attract new families.


Monday, November 17, 2008

The Pace of Growth

The national election is over; it is time to think ahead to the election of our next City Commission.

The current City Commission has favored developers and builders to the point of harming the community. The City Commission confuses growth in the supply of real estate with economic development. It is easy to be confused because a coalition of developers, builders, and others engaged in the real estate development industry incorrectly equate growth in supply with growth in demand. This coalition also gives lots of money to the election campaigns of pro-developer candidates who will listen to this false claim and act upon it by approving virtually every development proposal.

The truth is that economic development is the growth of the aggregate income within the community. This can be the result of increasing income among the existing population, usually from wages growing faster than inflation. This can also be the result of increasing the population itself with the new residents bringing new spending to the community.

With growth in aggregate income in the community comes growth in demand for real estate. More households seek more housing. More income increases demand for retail goods and services.

Without growth in aggregate income in the community, there is no growth in demand for real estate. More housing without more households simply causes neighborhoods to compete for a finite, and insufficient, number of households. More retail space without increased income simply spreads the finite amount of retail spending very thinly, with weaker shopping centers failing and becoming blighted.

The community is in need of a City Commission that understands the most basic tenet of real estate economics, that real estate development must be supported by growth in demand for that real estate. If real estate is allowed to grow faster than growth in demand, the older space and the older neighborhoods lose value. Developers make money when they overbuild, but the community suffers. The City takes on the costs of new infrastructure that is not needed. Older neighborhoods lose value and deteriorate. Older shopping centers lose value and become blighted, reducing the value of surrounding neighborhoods.

The next City Commission needs to call for, and act upon, good planning from its planning staff. This means monitoring the pace of growth and ensuring that the developers are not allowed to add subdivisions, shopping centers and other developments that are not needed.

Over the next few weeks, I will itemize some of the specifics of the overbuilding that has taken place in Lawrence along with the harm that this overbuilding has created.


For more on this pace of growth in Lawrence see my recent study at:

http://www.saup.ku.edu/People/UBPLFaculty/KirkMcClure/Pace%20of%20Growth%20Study.pdf

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Planning in Lawrence has failed

How the City has let the Growth of Supply Outpace the Growth of Demand


Lawrence has grown in population and income, and that is good. But the growth in real estate development has outpaced the demand for that real estate, and that is bad. It causes disinvestment and blight, and all too often the taxpayers suffer.

Housing

Since 2000, developers added about 800 units per year while the population growth would support only about 400 units per year.

The surplus has brought about an out-migration from older neighborhoods resulting in a loss of units. The loss of population and units resulted in a loss of value and deterioration in the city’s older neighborhoods.

Retail Development

Inflation adjusted growth in retail spending since 2000 is growing at 0.2 percent per year, enough to support about only 25,000 to 30,000 additional square feet per year.

From 2000 through 2007, the stock of retail square feet is growing at 3.1 percent or about 150,000 square feet per year.

The developers added about 1.3 million square feet beyond what the growth in retail spending could support. This is approximately the size of the retail space in the entire downtown or about one-fourth of the total stock of space.

The situation is rapidly becoming worse as an additional 750,000 square feet of space have been approved for West 6th Street from Folks Road to the South Lawrence Trafficway. If all of this space is built, it will swell the stock of surplus space to over two million square feet.

The surplus development has stalled redevelopment plans downtown and has pushed the vacancy rates so high that disinvestment and blight now threaten several older shopping centers.

Industrial, Warehousing, and Office Development

Employment growth, like population growth, has slowed since 2000. It has declined for manufacturing and warehousing jobs but continues to grow slowly for office jobs.

Manufacturing space grows in incremental steps as facilities are added. However, there have been no significant additions to the stock of manufacturing space since 2003. Manufacturing space has stabilized with no additions because demand for the space is contracting rather than growing. This means that empty space is available on the market.

The supply of warehousing space is growing at about 2 percent per year, adding about 85,000 square feet each year. Warehouse space is growing despite declining employment. This means a surplus condition exists.


Office space is growing at about 2.3 percent per year, adding about 67,000 square feet each year, a rate close to the rate of growth in employment. The office sector is reasonably balanced with growth in supply closely matching growth in employment, but the market is negatively impacted by the surplus of retail space that is being offered as office space.


Conclusions

Allowing the supply of real estate to grow faster than growth in demand adds to costs. Unneeded roads, sewer lines, water lines are built to service this space. Police and fire protection must be provided even if the space is empty.

Growing supply faster than growth in demand does not stimulate more demand. Lawrence has been overbuilt for years. Yet, surplus housing has not attracted more population. Surplus retail stores have not attracted more vendors. Surplus industrial and warehouse space has not attracted more employers.

Growing supply faster than growth in demand causes older areas to deteriorate. Older neighborhoods are not receiving sufficient investment in the form of replacement homes and improvements to existing homes to maintain their value. Older neighborhoods are losing value, schools and people. Downtown, which is one of Lawrence’s strongest attractions, is stagnating and failing to attract vendors into its newly renovated shops.
Employment centers sit empty while the City rushes to build more.


Lessons to learn

Growth in supply is not growth in demand.

City and county leaders, and their planners, should view it as part of their job to fix a failure in the marketplace, which is the propensity to overbuild. These leaders should keep the growth of supply in balance with the growth in demand. This means limiting growth to just that amount that can be absorbed without harm to the community at large.

The community is overbuilt, and a long cooling off period is needed. The city should stop adding to the problem and work toward redirecting growth into existing space.

The community needs to stop the overbuilding and permit only very selective development that can clearly demonstrate that it responds to an unmet need, despite the surplus stock that exists.

In the housing sector, the city needs to take steps to redirect growth away from new sprawling subdivisions on the perimeter of the city and toward the older neighborhoods that are suffering from disinvestment and decay.

In the retail sector, the city needs to protect and enhance its downtown, the retail district that attracts the coveted tourist dollars. The city needs to stop the unneeded expansion of retail space at the perimeter of the city and help to redirect retail spending to the downtown and the other shopping centers distributed around the city.

In the industrial and office sector, the city needs to carefully gauge the pace of growth of employment and limit the expansion of employment centers, whether office parks, industrial parks, or other form of employment center, to just that level that can be absorbed.

None of these steps means a complete moratorium on development. Moratoria have been tried and failed in other communities. Except in a few short-term situations, they do not work. However, city leaders need to realize that the stock of real estate is in trouble largely because the city has pursued a pace of growth that cannot be sustained.

In the housing sector, the city should stop the development of any new subdivisions until it is clear that more are needed. Evidence of this would be found in low vacancies among existing homes and small inventories of homes for sale.

In the retail sector, the city should avoid adding to the problem by approving any more retail proposals. However, from time to time, a neighborhood center may be needed because it will serve a newer subdivision that does not have a neighborhood center. Despite the retail market being overbuilt, some small quantity of new space may be needed to service the homes in this new subdivision. However, the city has approved several new retail developments that, if built, will be harmful to the city as a whole. Some of these developments cannot go further because they are unable to obtain the needed leases to leverage loans from banks. The development permission given to these projects runs for 18 months. As this permission expires, it is customary for the city to grant extensions without scrutiny of the impact of these unneeded projects upon the remainder of the city. This should be stopped. Until such time as the city can easily absorb new space without hurting existing shopping districts, the city should stop renewing the development approvals. When these retail developments come up for renewal, they should be shelved.

In the industrial and office sector, the city should avoid adding to the problem of surplus employment centers. While land needs to be available for the small number of new firms that may locate in Lawrence, there is already an ample stock of unused and underutilized buildings. The city should make every effort to make use of these structures before sprawling into new sites. In addition, the city should make every effort to use the existing employment center land before bringing more onto the market. Sprawling development, whether housing or manufacturing or office space, adds unnecessary and costly public improvements, and it stretches city services that are already stretched.

Monday, April 21, 2008

Which city, Overland Park or Lawrence, is practicing smart growth?

Lawrence has been on a spree of approving retail shopping centers that are not needed. The City Commission approved a second Wal-Mart. It approved another shopping center at 6th and Wakarusa, far beyond the square footage called for at that intersection. It approved two large shopping centers at 6th and the South Lawrence Trafficway.

This excessive approval of retail development proposals has been going on for some time, and it is harmful to the community. It hurts the downtown generally by siphoning spending away. It makes it impossible to complete various downtown redevelopment projects, such as Downtown 2000, which has left the taxpayers paying for an empty parking garage building. It hurts the capacity of other downtown projects to attract tenants, such as the Hobbs-Taylor building. It adds to the stock of vacant and deteriorating space found all over town.

Lawrence has developed retail space at a growth rate of 3.0 percent per year from 1995 through 2007. Yet, inflation adjusted retail spending--a good measure of demand for this space--has grown by only 0.9 percent per year during the same time period. Thus, Lawrence has allowed its supply of retail space to grow at over three times the pace of growth of demand for that space. This means that new space, if absorbed at all, simply takes demand away from existing space. The result is widespread vacancy, deterioration, and blight.

Overland Park is a nearby city confronting similar growth problems. It is interesting to note that Overland Park has kept the pace of growth of retail supply in line with the growth in demand for that supply. From 1990 through 2007, inflation adjusted retail spending in Overland Park grew by 2.1 percent per year. During the same years, Overland Park allowed its stock of retail space to grow by 1.7 percent per year.

Overland Park is practicing smart growth. It is keeping the growth in supply in balance with the growth in demand. As a result Overland Park’s retail market is in much better shape than is Lawrence’s retail market. Lawrence is not practicing smart growth, and it is paying the price.

What happens when developers control the pace of growth?

The Planning Commission tends to worsen these mistakes by granting the developers unlimited extensions of time in which to develop. When these developments initially go before the Planning Commission and the City Commission, they promise to initiate development within 18 months. Several have failed to move forward because they cannot find sufficient tenants. Rather than admit a mistake, they ask for--and receive--extensions of time to look for tenants. The Planning Commission should admit the mistakes of approving these unneeded developments and refuse the extensions.

Lawrence city government is controlled by the coalition of developers who contributed heavily to get pro-developer individuals elected to the City Commission. These elected pro-developer city commissioners have appointed pro-developer friends to the Planning Commission. This means that developers are getting all that they ask for, even when it runs contrary to the community’s plan which calls for balanced growth.

There is value in smart growth. It prevents loss of value to existing centers. It protects the existing downtown. It helps maintain a healthy level of investment in existing shopping centers. It promotes redevelopment plans.

Lawrence is losing value rapidly. Smart growth can help resolve that problem, but we need leadership that understands the harm that results from letting developers set the pace of growth. We need leadership that understands that smart growth will not happen by itself; we need to consciously plan for our future and work hard to achieve it.


What does the tax abatement report really say?


On Friday, the Lawrence Journal World stated, “The [Public Incentives Review] committee on Thursday unanimously approved its annual report, finding that all eight companies receiving tax breaks are in compliance with the city’s economic development policies.”


This is not what the Public Incentives Review Committee (PIRC) did. The PIRC made no finding of compliance or lack of it. Rather, the PIRC swept the high level of non-compliance under the rug as it has for many years in the past.


The newspaper also said, “In total the companies had exceeded their job creation projections by 87 full-time jobs and 123 part-time jobs.” This is a case of looking at the glass as one-quarter full rather than three-quarters empty.
Here are the facts:



· In terms of making the promised investments, of the 11 currrent abatements, only 8 delivered, 2 fell well short, and 1 chose to lease the property.


· In terms of paying wages at or above the average found in the community, 4 of the 8 firms have substantial numbers of workers being paid from $3 to $6 per hour below the community average within each occupation group.


· In terms of producing the promised jobs, 4 firms fulfilled their promises, 1 firm fell 2 workers below the promised amont, and 3 fell well below the promised job production.




It is true that the total number of jobs at all firms given tax abatements is in excess of the total number of jobs promised. The firms that met the promised number of jobs produced more extra jobs than the shortfall experienced by the firms that failed to meet their promises. However, this statistic would have merit only if the jobs would not have been generated in the absence of the tax abatement. This is simply not the case.

The tax abatement is a needless giveaway. The firms would have produced the jobs without the tax abatement. Some of the firms have made public statements to this effect. All of the published research on tax abatements finds this to be true. Property taxes are too small a percentage of a firm’s total operating expenses to be crucial to the decision to build or expand. However, lower taxes are always helpful to enhance profits; thus, firms ask for the tax abatements even when they are not important to the decision to build or expand. The firms will even lie to the City saying that without the tax abatement the firm cannot build or expand.

What the report shows is that Lawrence has an ongoing problem with its tax abatement program. In a normal economic development program, non-compliance should be minimal. The PIRC should be discussing what to do with no more that one firm that is out of compliance. Instead, the PIRC is trying to cover up the fact that non-compliance is normal in Lawrence. Six of the eight firms are substantially out of compliance in at least one of the important areas or investment, wages, or jobs. This is not a new or temporary condition; it has been going on for years.

The City has been misled. It has been told by business advocacy organizations, such as the Chamber of Commerce, that tax abatements are needed to attract firms even though the experience both locally and nationally says the opposite. The City has been led into a position of offering abatements, almost automatically, to firms just for the asking. Yet, these firms fail to make the promised investments, fail to pay wages comparable to other firms in the community, and fail to produce the promised jobs. In many cases, the firms go out of business before the City can hope to realize any benefits. (Note that the PIRC report is deficient in that it only reports on existing abatements; it does not report of the firms that have been given abatements that went out of business such as Davol or E&E.)

An ongoing problem of non-compliance hurts the City. Not only does the City not get the jobs and wages and taxes promised, but it cannot negotiate effectively with future firms. Word is out; Lawrence is a pushover town. A firm can promise much, produce little, and still keep its tax break.

The City of Lawrence is confronting a severe budget problem. Revenues are not flowing into the City as expected. Planned expansion of the library has been scrapped. Social service agencies saw their budgets cut (although the Chamber of Commerce was given even more taxpayer money to further its failed economic development activities). Discussion has already been started on possible elimination of the bus system, the public transit needed by many people of low-income. We would all have been better served if we had not offered needless giveaways to firms in the form of tax abatements. Those lost tax revenues are sorely needed.


Saturday, April 12, 2008

How should Lawrence conduct its economic development efforts?

It is time to change the role of the Chamber of Commerce.


Recent developments present an opportunity.

The City of Lawrence, Kansas does not conduct its economic development planning through city staff. Rather, the City hires the Chamber of Commerce to conduct these tasks.

In the wake of controversy and legal embarrassment, the Chamber of Commerce is about to replace its Executive Director.

This provides an opportunity for the City to rethink how it goes about conducting its economic development efforts.



Definition of economics development.

Economic development means helping a city achieve higher levels of employment as well as attracting higher levels of tax revenue from non-residential sources than would otherwise be the case. This usually involves:

Outreach: This means advertising the City to prospective businesses who might locate here.

Subsidy packages: This means generating analysis to determine whether or not the city should offer incentive packages to firms to locate here or to firms already here that may expand. These incentives may come in many forms. They may take the form of tax reduction through rebates or refunds. They may offer financial assistance through various forms of loans, which may come at below market interest rates. They may offer cost reduction through providing land, buildings, and infrastructure at reduced prices.

Planning: This means conducting research to identify weaknesses in the local economy and to identify the needs of the community in the future. This research should monitor which sectors of the economy suffer from the greatest levels of unemployment and underemployment. It should also project the needs of the community for future employment and use this research to guide future actions.


Current state of economic development in Lawrence.

For many years, the City has hired the Chamber of Commerce to conduct its economic development activities. The Chamber provides some outreach services. The Chamber has supported numerous applications for subsidy packages from the City to private firms without analyzing the need for the subsidy packages. The Chamber conducts little to no planning research.


The record.

The record of the Chamber of Commerce in the field of economic development is one of failure.


Tax Abatements:

The Chamber has actively led the City into a large list of tax abatements. Of the 17 firms granted abatements:

· Only 6 produced the promised jobs and wages.
· The remaining 11 are either out of compliance, out of business, or not reporting.

This record of success is unimpressive. The abatements are:

· Successful only: 35% of the time;
· Non-compliant:
40% of the time; and
· Complete failure: 25% of the time.

(See Annual Reports of the Public Incentives Review Committee.)


Secret meetings:

The Chamber actively sponsored secret meetings to arrange for packages of taxpayer-funded subsidies to private firms. The parties at these meetings included the City Commission, the buyers of the property, and the sellers of the property. The only people excluded were the taxpayers. The Attorney General found these meetings to be in violation of the Kansas Open Meetings Act. (See “AG: City leaders broke law: Morrison proposes open meetings training for settlement” Lawrence Journal World December 1, 2007.)


Failed projects:

The Chamber has led the City into failed projects. The Chamber recently held a celebration of its accomplishments in a building developed, at least partially, at taxpayers’ expense that has remained vacant for years. Many other failures such as Serologicals and Decyphera exist. (See Mark Fagan, “Business Park Marks 20 Years,” Lawrence Journal World April 1, 2008.)


Enforcement:

Chamber staff actively resisted any and all efforts by the Public Incentives Review Committee to investigate the level of compliance by firms with the terms of their tax abatements. (See Minutes of the Public Incentives Review Committee.)


Lack of Planning:

The Chamber conducts virtually no planning in its economic development exercises. It has supported proposals for such grandiose projects as the development of 1,000 acres of industrial park space, yet it has failed to produce any planning analysis that would justify such a large facility. (Lawrence Journal World, Group recommends 1,000 acres to assist in creation of jobs, December 5, 2001.)


Lack of Analytical Skills:

The City has recently fielded requests from the developer of the Oread hotel for subsidy through the Tax Increment Financing and Transportation Development District programs. The City had to hire outside consultants to review the subsidy request because neither the City staff nor the Chamber staff possess the capabilities to perform this type of analysis.


What Lawrence needs.

Lawrence needs to bring economic development skills inside City Hall.

The Chamber of Commerce is a business advocacy organization. Economic development strategies need to be good for business, but, more importantly, they need to be good for the City and its taxpayers. Everything that is good for business is not necessarily good for the City and its taxpayers. The Chamber has shown itself to advocate for the interests of business at the expense of the interests of the City.

Lawrence needs intelligent, knowledgeable, highly skilled economic development leadership that is an advocate for the City and its taxpayers.

Lawrence needs economic development planners that can guide the City through detailed negotiations with firms to ensure that a subsidy package, if any, is in the City’s best long-run interests, not simply a giveaway to any business that asks.

Lawrence needs economic development planners that can accurately project the City’s future needs without exaggeration or bias.

Lawrence needs economic development planners that will be open and transparent in the development and analysis of subsidy packages and will understand the confines of the law prohibiting secret meetings.

Lawrence needs economic development planners who will enforce the terms of agreements between the City and private firms receiving taxpayer dollars.



Recommendation.

It is time for Lawrence to learn the difference between economic development and business advocacy.


Redefine the role of the Chamber.

The Chamber has lost the respect of the taxpayers by leading the City Commission into failed projects, into illegal meetings, and into tax giveaways that do not produce as promised. The Chamber’s role in economic development should be redefined. The Chamber needs to be heard as economic development issues arise, but the Chamber should not be performing any of the analysis or planning duties.


Bring professional economic development planning expertise onto the City staff.

Bring the job of economic development inside City Hall. Increase the skill level of the planning staff to include:

· Analysis of the feasibility of real estate development projects so that the need for subsidy can be determined by someone who interests lie with the City and not with the businesses who will be subsidized,

· Analysis of market conditions so as to determine the true need for commercial and industrial space, protecting the City from engaging in unneeded industrial parks, retail centers, or office parks that will further expand the surpluses that already exist, and

· Analysis of existing programs to fairly assess their effectiveness so that they can be expanded when they succeed and redesigned or discontinued when they fail.

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Should Lawrence adopt the Smartcode?

Is the Smartcode worthy of its name?

“Smart growth, or sustainable development, has been tested as a policy in at least two-dozen states since the 1970s, when the term first appeared. It's evolved over the decades, to be sure, but the chief goals remain: to plan better, rein in sprawl, redevelop in established urban areas, promote mixed-use growth near transit and in environments that are easy to walk around, and offer a range of housing types that are affordable to different incomes. “ - Lincoln Land Institute Smart Growth: Form and Consequences (2002).

The Smartcode does nothing to rein in sprawl, it works against the redevelopment of established areas, and it does not ensure that development proceeds at a sustainable pace. While it makes a nod to mixed-use and the ability to walk around, it does nothing to ensure that affordable housing is provided in new developments. As such, the Smartcode fails to deliver what it promises.

The Smartcode is a poorly designed development code that removes most public input from the development process and circumvents needed review of many development projects by both the Planning Commission and the City Commission.

The basics are as follows:

Certain districts would be designated as appropriate for development. Once designated and zoned, no further public input is permitted on any development proposal. Yet, we know from experience that citizens rarely become involved in the zoning process; they only become involved when a development proposal comes forward.

If a developer plans a development within these districts, and if a committee of planning staff members (called the Consolidated Review Committee or CRC) finds that the architectural design of the development meets the design guidelines of the Smartcode, then a building permit is issued.

There is no review by the Planning Commission, and there is no review by the City Commission. Because public input is only received through hearings before these two bodies, there is no public input on the process.

The Smartcode assumes that if land is zoned, that the developer can build at any time with only cursory staff review. If the market cannot absorb the new development without negative impact upon existing space, the Smartcode does not prevent this negative impact. In fact, it facilitates growth at an unsustainable pace.
If the CRC does not approve the development plan, the developer may appeal to the Planning Commission. There is no obligation for the CRC to inform the public of the development plan or seek out public input. If the public does learn of the development plan, it has no capacity to provide input. The public cannot appeal the decision of the CRC to either the Planning Commission or the City Commission.

The Smartcode calls for subsidies to certain types of developments that meet the architectural guidelines within the code. It is apparent that the Smartcode calls for subsidies to development that will take place without subsidy and fails to assist development in older neighborhoods that will not take place without subsidy. This is wasteful and counterproductive.


Good design does not resolve all planning problems

Smartcode is a needless giveaway to the developers. The Smartcode derives from a false belief that if development meets certain design guidelines, that all of the other planning and developments problems resulting from the proposal are resolved. It would be nice if beautiful architecture could overcome all the other problems, but it cannot. There is nothing in the Smartcode that prevents the development community from its continued overbuilding. If the district is zoned and if the development plan meets certain architectural guidelines, then the development can obtain its building permit even if the neighbors object and even if the development will have a negative impact upon other parts of the community (such as traffic congestion or adding to an already overbuilt supply of space).

The planning staff made a few modifications to the initial draft of the Smartcode by agreeing that the CRC will examine a developer provided market analysis and traffic impact study. The staff has not demonstrated either the skill or the willingness to respond appropriately to market studies in the past. There is nothing in the Smartcode mandating attention to these issues now. Further, there is little reason to believe that developer provided studies will tell the truth. In Lawrence, we have seen many false reports, making phony claims and exaggerated promises. For every piece of failed real estate, there is a market study saying the property would succeed. The planning staff have accepted and approved these studies in the past. They have made few, if any, efforts to correct these studies or to create their own studies. This record does not suggest that the public can trust the planning staff to do better in the future.


Building space faster than growth in demand for that space

The greatest threat to Lawrence is the excessive pace of growth in the supply of real estate. The community should expect, even demand, good design without offering subsidies or accelerated access to building permits. The community should be a part of the development process from the zoning decision all the way through to the final development plan approval.

The development industry confuses growth in supply with growth in demand. Economic growth is assessed by the growth in demand, which is the growth in people and their income. When we have more people and these people have more income, then their spending will demand more goods and services.

These goods and services may include more homes and support more retail stores. Note that building more homes and stores does not generate more people or income. Demand must precede supply and support supply. If supply is built beyond the available demand, then bad things happen. Older shopping centers empty out and become blighted. Older neighborhoods decline. Developers never pick up the cost of this blight; they simply look to the taxpayers to pay the very expensive costs of redevelopment. Even this expensive redevelopment fails unless there is sufficient demand for the revitalized space.


Sustainable growth means supply growing no faster than the growth in demand

It is crucial to the health of any community that the growth in supply be kept at a pace that matches the growth in demand. Unfortunately, the development and construction industries are prone to overbuilding. Cities, under pressure from developers, are prone to over-zoning. This is true throughout the nation, not just here in Lawrence. Preventing excessive growth in supply is easy and costless; it only takes well-managed growth controls by the community.

This is the purpose of the market analysis requirement integrated into the planning process. Lawrence has ignored this analysis because it has, for years, indicated that Lawrence is building more homes than it needs and more retail space than it needs and more office space than it needs. Developers and builders have brought political pressure on the planners to ignore the market signals indicating that the market is building at an unsustainable pace. Except at the extreme, developers make money even in overbuilt markets. Thus, the builders and developers have captured control of the political process to prevent the community from taking steps to slow the pace of growth.

What Lawrence needs is smart growth management tools not misnamed smart development codes that are giveaways to a development industry that has proven itself prone to overbuilding.

Lawrence should not adopt the Smartcode and should actively work toward bringing the pace of real estate development in line with the growth in demand for that development.



Friday, January 18, 2008

Oread Inn, Eldridge Expansion, and TIF Loans

How should the City approach reqests for TIF and TDD financing?

The developers of the Oread Inn (the Fritzel family) bring a very interesting project to the community. It may be a project worth the community’s investment, but the devil is in the details. The community needs to be very careful with its scarce resources, including its future tax revenues. The community should subsidize commercial projects like these hotel proposals only:

  • Where it is sure that the net result is beneficial to the community, and
  • The financial commitment is not one dollar more than is minimally necessary for the project to move forward.

Here are the basics of the Oread Inn proposal:

The development will cost about $31 million. Of this total, about $6 million is for a parking garage and $5 million is for off-site improvements (road, pipes, walks, etc.) The developer will finance about $20 million, and the city will finance about $11 million (the parking garage and the off-site improvements) though Tax Increment Financing (TIF) bonds and Transportation Development District (TDD) bonds.

TIF bonds are bonds sold to investors through the normal bond market. However, these bonds are sold with the understanding that the revenue to repay the principal and interest on the bonds will come from pledging some or all of the incremental taxes generated by the project. Thus, the project will pay to the city, county, and school district the taxes that would have been collected from these properties had no new development taken place. The taxes collected above these original levels, called the tax increment, can be pledged to repay the TIF bond debt. Kansas law permits some or all of the city and county tax increments to be pledged to repay TIF bond debt. Kansas law prevents all of the school tax increment from being pledged to repay TIF bond debt; a portion of the new tax revenues must be given to the school district. To the extent that portions of these city, county, or school district taxes are pledged to repay TIF bonds, these future tax revenues are lost to local government. Until the debt is retired, government services will have to be paid by other taxpayers.

TDD bonds are very similar to TIF bonds. The difference is that the tax revenues pledged to repay the bonds come from a special sales tax that is added to the properties within the district. This TDD tax giveaway is of less concern to a community than the TIF giveaway because, if used appropriately, all of the tax revenue comes from non-residents (i.e.: tourists staying at the hotel). There is no capacity for the city to impose the tax without pledging it to repay TDD bonds; thus, there is no loss of future tax revenue to the city as there is with the TIF.

What the developer wants

The developer wants all legally available local taxes generated by this project pledged to repay the bonds. The developer has offered a letter of credit to fully cover the debt on the bonds in the event of default by the property. Thus, the city cannot suffer out-of-pocket losses on this project, but the city will not see any tax revenues from this project until the bonds are fully repaid. This could be as long as twenty years.

Some of the taxes that would come to the city from this project will go to paying for the hotel’s parking garage. As such, these funds will not be available to meet the city’s other needs. Also, some of the taxes that would come to the city from this project will go to paying for the hotel's road, sidewalk, and utility line improvements that would not otherwise be needed by the city.

The city's decision process

What this means is that the taxpayers are giving property taxes from this development back to the development itself. If the community believes that this project will be so beneficial that it merits this return of taxes, then it may be a subsidy deal worth undertaking. Unfortunately, the process is not designed to help us make this assessment.

What the developer is offering is:

Option 1: A 7-story hotel (7 stories above Oread Avenue with 3 stories of garage below) which would require 20 years to retire the TIF bonds.

Option 2: An 8 or more story hotel (with condominium units on the top stories) which could permit repayment of the TIF bonds in ten years bringing the property onto the tax roles much earlier.

The developer claims that the project is not feasible without the TIF bonds. This may or may not be true. The city can and should determine the accuracy of this claim by careful examination of the developer’s projected expenses and revenues. It is possible that that a smaller project would be feasible with no tax increment financing. It is possible that the project, as proposed, is feasible with TIF bonds paying only for portion of the public improvements and the parking garage.

It is unclear if anyone within city hall is examining these issues and guiding the negotiations toward an optimal design for this project from the perspective of the taxpayers.

The developer is doing a masterful job of boxing the city into a corner. The city should hold off on the deciding about the historic issues, the zoning issues, or the design issues for now. First it should decide what is the best option for the city and negotiate for that option. However, the developer is pushing ahead on these issues so that the city effectively will be given a “take it or leave it” choice. This is unfortunate and should be avoided.

The developer is also planning a similar expansion of the Eldridge Hotel downtown. It wants to expand the hotel to the west to Vermont Street with underground parking, conference facilities and additional rooms. It is very likely that a similar or even larger TIF and TDD request will be made for the Eldridge.

The process that the city is following is reminiscent of the process followed years ago to approve the financing of the parking garage on the 900 block of New Hampshire. The process ensured that the financing was legal, but the process did not ensure that it was beneficial to the city. As a result, the city is now paying for a parking garage for which it is struggling to find cars. Much of the concern over the Oread Inn financing is resolved with the letter of credit guarantee offered by the developer. However, much remains unresolved.

Being legal is not enough; the project should be beneficial to the city and avoid any unnecessary giveaway of much needed tax revenues.

The city has hired a consultant to address the feasibility issues. This feasibility study is to be completed by January 30th. The city has published a “calendar of events for TIF and TDD” for review and approval of the Oread Inn project. The calendar provides no time for negotiations between the city and the developer. Rather, the calendar is couched entirely in terms that assume approval of the developer defined proposal. The calendar’s language assumes the developer alone defines the proposal; there is no provision for negotiations and modifications by the city. Further, the calendar assumes approval of the developer’s proposal at each and every step along the way. There is no conditional language stating that approval at a later stage is conditioned upon approval at an earlier stage. There is no decision tree showing alternative paths that may be taken to a negotiated agreement if the city agrees to partner with the developer in the building and financing of this hotel.



What should happen next?

The city should take command of the approval process and enter into negotiations with the developer. The city should seek to maximize the tax revenues that can flow to the city from this hotel. Giving away all of the tax revenue means that the city’s economy gains a few jobs, but the city must provide police and fire protection to the hotel plus other services for which it will not be compensated. It also means that the city will lose this hotel as a source of much needed revenues to pay for the ever growing costs of running the city. To maximize these revenues, the city must negotiate with the developer on alternative development schemes that may reduce the need to tax increment financing.

These questions need to be answered:

1. Will more hotel rooms permit the bonds to be repaid earlier, bringing the property onto the tax roles earlier?

2. Can alternative design schemes be feasible without pledging all of the tax dollars to the project?

It is the role of the city Manager and the Director of Development to assure the taxpayers that these issues are being addressed. Both are relatively new to their positions. Being new, neither has developed a track record of prior success in such negotiations that can build public trust.

We cannot afford to sit back and depend upon the developer to propose a scheme that is optimal for the city. Provision of TIF and TDD bonds is a significant participation by the city. If the city is to become a partner in this development, city staff members need to take a lead role in the examination of alternative design schemes which may be better for the taxpayers.


Wednesday, July 25, 2007

What happens when the Planning Commission does not plan?

The Lawrence-Douglas County Planning Commission consciously defined itself as the "land use" commission when it reviewed the development plan for the city's second Wal-Mart, this one to be located at 6th Street and Wakarusa Drive. Anytime a planning commission shirks its duty to plan and attempts to redefine itself as something less, such as a "land use" commission, a city is hurt.



On July 23rd, the Planning Commission reviewed the development plan for the second Wal-Mart. The Chair of the Planning Commission stated, "We are the land use commission". With this statement, the Chair asserted that the role of the Planning Commission is very narrow, that of administering zoning ordinances that specify the height, size, and use of buildings. Zoning administration is part of the job of the Planning Commission, but this is far short of all of its full job.

Horizon 2020 is the comprehensive plan for the community. The zoning ordinance and zoning map derive from this plan, but they are not the whole of the plan. The plan calls for the city to monitor the pace of growth of retail space and to protect and preserve the city's existing retail districts.



Maintaining the proper pace of growth is crucial to the success of a city. If the retail space grows too fast, the new space will be occupied, but the surplus will cause older space to become vacant, to deteriorate, and to cause blight. If a city can pace the growth of retail space so that the pace of growth in supply is balanced with the pace of growth in demand, then the retail market can remain healthy.



In the absence of such planning, a city is letting the developers determine the pace of growth of retail supply. History shows that developers are prone to overbuilding. Lawrence is particularly troubled with overbuilding as the supply of space has been growing at three times the pace of growth in retail spending over a period of 12 years. This is a long-term problem. A twelve-year period is not a short-term fluctuation; it is a chronic problem. The harm of this overbuilding is that is causes widespread vacancy in older commercial districts, causing loss in investment, loss in value to surrounding neighborhoods, and lost public investment in revitalization. In Lawrence, the problem is so widespread that the retail oversupply has spread to the office market as dead malls seek out office tenants to avoid total vacancy. This depletes demand from the office market, hurting its capacity to survive.



The Planning Commission chose to ignore these issues. When it narrowly defined itself as the "land use" commission, it took the position that if the land is zoned for commercial space, that the developer, not the community, decides when that land is developed. It is this type of thinking that has generated many of Lawrence's real estate problems. It perpetuates the overbuilding that has resulted in:



1. A blighting level of vacancy in North Lawrence,

2. New retail space downtown unable to attract tenants,

3. Wasted large-scale investment in downtown revitalization with the new parking garage unable to leverage new commercial development,

4. Office usage of retail space in several malls along 23rd Street, and

5. Widespread vacant and deteriorating retail stores.



There is little doubt that adding a second Wal-Mart (or any other store of this scale) will add no new spending to the community. It will only displace retail spending from other stores. Thus, adding this new space will only vacate space elsewhere. The City currently suffers from:



1. Over 300,000 square feet of surplus vacant space (vacant space beyond a normal 5% vacancy rate),

2. Over 800,000 square feet of retail space in the planning process (including the Wal-Mart proposal), and

3. An ability to absorb only about 50,000 square feet per year given the pace of growth of retail spending.



The arithmetic is sobering. If no more space were to be built, it would take 6 years to absorb just the surplus vacant space that exists now. If all of the proposed space is built (Wal-Mart, Bauer Farms, Northgate, and Mercato), it will take an additional 16 years to fill all of this space.



The space may be built, and most of it may be occupied early in its lifespan, but the result will be continued widespread vacancy, deterioration, and blight elsewhere in the community. This can be avoided if the Planning Commission ceases to be narrowly defined zoning administrator and becomes what it is called upon to be, a commission that plans.